Types of Carabiners & What kN Ratings Mean | ITS Tactical
 

Types of Carabiners and What kN Ratings Mean

By The ITS Crew

Types of Carabiners

Today we offer a post to try to clear up some of the confusion surrounding carabiners, and what that kN thing means.

Carabiners come in many shapes and sizes and are purpose built for many different climbing applications.

We’ve highlighted the main variations of climbing carabiners as well as what we feel the positives and negatives are.

Types-of-Carabiners-01

The carabiners referenced below are specifically for climbing, and  if a type of carabiner is not listed here, then it’s probably not recommend it for climbing.

We’re specifically referring to oval carabiners, which are more for clipping gear to a harness, but not recommended for climbing due to where the rope sits.

Unlike the “D” or symmetrical shape carabiners, which shift the rope towards the spine and away from the gate, oval carabiners keep the rope dangerously close to the gate.

Types of Carabiners

Snap Gate Carabiners

Snap gate carabiners are designed for leading a climbing route and offer fast clipping and simplicity when placing protection.  They are also typically used for clipping gear to a harness.

The  two main categories of snap gates are solid gate and wire gate, which come in two available configurations, straight and bent.

Solid Gate

Solid gate carabiners tend to weigh more and are quickly being replaced by wire gates. Weight isn’t the only reason though, there’s an inherent design flaw to solid gate carabiners called gate flutter. This happens primarily when the rope runs through the carabiner at speed for an extended duration, causing solid gate carabiners to open and close rapidly due to the mass of the gate.

Here’s a test to prove it. Take a solid, snap gate carabiner and knock the spine against the palm of your hand. Hear that click? That was the solid gate opening and closing rapidly. If that happened under load on a climb, it’s possible for the vibration to open it enough for something bad to happen.

Wire Gate

First and foremost, a wire gate prevents the aforementioned problem with the solid gate carabiners opening and closing during full-loading.

Less mass in the gate and not being as prone to vibration are the factors in prevention. This also reduces weight which makes sense when your carrying multiple carabiners.

Another tremendous benefit to wire gate carabiners are that there are  no moving parts to break, get stuck, or freeze. Solid gates have an internal spring within the gate, which makes them prone to failure.

Wire gates retain their spring through the way the wire is placed in the carabiner when it’s built.

Straight Gate

Straight gates are the standard in carabiners, and for a good reason. It’s a trusted design and not prone to the dangers of bent gates, which we’ll explain below.

Most wire gates are also straight gates, but there are bent wire-gates manufactured (see photo below). Typically though, the bent gates you’ll see will be solid gates.

Bent Gate

BentWireGateThe bent gate design allows you to clip-in easier, making it better for hard to reach places. The dangers of using a bent gate carabiner, are that it could become undone  if another carabiner or object is pressed against it.

If you do use a bent gate, don’t clip them into the protection side of your system, use them on the rope side. This is just in case they become twisted or inverted by the rope.

Screw Gate Carabiners

Also referred to as locking carabiners, screw gate carabiners feature a sleeve that can be tightened to prevent accidental opening of the gate.

The two main categories of screw gates are symmetrical and asymmetrical, which come in two different configurations, manual or automatic locking gate.

Symmetrical

The design of a symmetrical or “D” shaped carabiner automatically aligns rope and attached runners to the spine of the carabiner. This is where the greatest strength lies in a carabiner, and is why it’s the most common design.

It’s also why we mentioned not to use oval carabiners, as they align rope and runners to the mid-point because there’s no spine.

Asymmetrical

You may have read in our rappelling articles that we refer to asymmetrical carabiners as “Lead” carabiners. This is because they have a  larger “pear shaped” gate opening, and a better angle to use when clipping in during top roping and lead climbing.

The downfall is that they have less space inside then symmetrical carabiners do.  Yes, looks can be deceiving. It looks as though they have more room, but when the larger gate is opened it takes up more space within the carabiner.

Manual Locking Gate

The most common screw gate carabiner features a rotating sleeve that is “screwed down so you don’t screw up!” How many of you remembered that tip from the rappelling articles?

That simply means that when using a screw gate carabiner, be sure to orient it so that the direction the sleeve travels is down. This will prevent the screw gate from further rotation by gravity if it should become loose.

Another tip is to not over-tighten the rotating sleeve, It can become stuck and difficult to loosen.

Automatic Locking Gate

The last style of screw gate carabiners feature an automatic locking gate, available in either single or dual stage.

Single stage is opened with a simple rotation of the gate to unlock it, and dual stage requires that button is depressed prior to rotating the gate to unlock.

Most climbers stay away from automatic locking gates, because more moving parts equals more parts to fail. This was a reason above that the wire gate carabiners are favored by some, as there’s no mechanical spring in the gate.

kN Rating

All carabiners come with a kN, or kiloNewton rating engraved into the spine. If you have carabiners without a kN rating DO NOT use them for climbing!

A kiloNewton is equal to about 225 lbs., which is a force of gravity rating, not static weight or mass. If you remember back to algebra class, force is equal to mass times acceleration.

Everything you use for climbing, rope, webbing, carabiners, anchors and protection is designed to absorb the force (or shock) that’s generated by a fall.

All this equipment has a certain rating of force it can withstand, and that rating is typically referred to as a kN rating.

That rating doesn’t take into account wear and tear on your gear, so always check everything before use, and replace anything with excessive wear.

Strength

We mentioned previously that the greatest strength of a carabiner is in its spine, and is why kN ratings typically offer two different strength ratings. One if the load is distributed along the spine, and another if the load somehow gets distributed across the gate.

Obviously, distributing a load on the gate of the carabiner isn’t good, and this is evident by the kN rating which will typically be 1/3 of what the spine rating is. For example, the manually locking carabiner in our photos is rated at kN 27 along the spine, and kN 8 to 9 across the gate.

If you really look at the construction of carabiners you’ll see why they’re rated less along this axis. All that’s holding the gate to the carabiner is a pin where the spring portion of the gate is located.

As you can imagine, an aluminum pin of that size can not offer a comparable load rating vs. the spine of the entire carabiner.

Don’t get us wrong, 8 to 9 kN is still almost 2000 lbs. of force that the pin can take, but wouldn’t you feel safer knowing you were protected by 27 kN (6000+ lbs.).

Here’s a simple calculator to convert kN to force pounds.

Notes

We’ve tried to hammer home the most important things to take away from carabiners and kN ratings, such as their inherent design flaws in some cases, as well as why kN ratings are important to take into consideration.

If there’s anything we didn’t mention, or any questions you have, ask away!

Are you getting more than 14¢ of value per day from ITS?

Thanks to the generosity of our supporting members, we’ve eliminated annoying ads and obtrusive content. We want your experience here at ITS to be beneficial and enjoyable.

At ITS, our goal is to provide different methods, ideas and knowledge that could one day save your life. If you’re interested in supporting our mission and joining our growing community of supporters, click below to learn more.

Discussion

  • So what your saying is I shouldn’t rappel with the keyring Biner I bought at home depot? 😉
    Very informative, haven’t heard this much knowledge on Carabiners since HRST Master class. Thanks for putting out the knowledge!

    • LOL, Doc that probably has a negative kN rating!

      Thanks for the kind words, and glad you enjoyed the article!
      Bryan

  • Storm1

    Thanks for the article, very informative!!
    (I was one that requested this) answered all my questions..very nice!!

    • Storm,

      Glad you liked the article, and thanks for the suggestion! We’d planned a kN rating article, but after your email we decided to make it more comprehensive.

      Bryan

  • NASA TOW

    You forgot to mention the auto locking solid gate variant, even though you have them pictured above, which do not suffer from the issues of the non-locking solid gate, and are far superior than the wire gate models for many applications. We use these exclusively for rigging much heavier load applications than simple human climbing.

    Thank you for the KN rating explanations. It helps explain it to others that don’t understand.

    • NASA TOW

      Oops. Missed it in the article.

  • Phillip N.

    Hello to all and a big “thanks” to all the people who helped and contributed to the startup of this website as I find it both fun and useful. Bear with my rusty English please…

    I want to stress a point that might be of some concern as it is related to safety issues. The issue/question mainly is: “Does the KN rating provided by a manufacturer of a carabiner, refer to static or dynamic loading?”. To make myself clear… static loading is a load applied gradually… if possible in a infinite amount of time (e.g. geological pressure on a bedrock. While a dynamic load is applied in a very short period of time (e.g. on a seat-belt in a car accident). Since biners are meant to gold a person even -and especially- while he is falling (and that is a dynamic load), if a rating is indicative of a dynamic load then static load of that biner is greater (the dynamic factor is always greater than 1.00)!

    Just my two cents… but I would appreciate an answer!
    Phillip

  • Simon

    Thanks for the info on carabiners, I was looking for a describtion of the double action carabiner? Do you know what that is? Thanks

    • Glad you found the info useful Simon, I’m not sure what a double action carabiner is referring to? Possible a double sided carabiner like the Nite Ize?

  • Art

    Hi,
    Thank you for the article. What about industrial equipment ratings? The snap hook on my full body harness at work has 5M stamped on the hook and 3.6M on the gate. What do those mean?
    Thanks in advance.

  • Kent

    Great article! Very informative. Do you have any links to good places to buy quality carabiner?

    Thanks,

    Kent

  • Rick De Leon

    I work in the electrical utility industry. We make heavy lifts for electrical equipment installations. Some employees are using a “Pear Shape Kwiklock ANSI Hook (Z359.1 2007). Most of our lifts are straight up and down. I am trying to find out what the SWL or WLL of this carabiner is. Can you help. I might add that I am a training instructor for this company and don’t want anyone to get hurt. Any information is really appreciated.
    Is there a website that has capacity information for carabiners.
    Thank you for your time.

  • Kurt

    @Rick De Leon Carabiners are not designed for continuous loads, using them in this fashion will cause micro fractures that will in turn cause it to break under significantly less weight. Id suggest using a screw pin safety shackle, they are cheaper and much safer to use for this application, as they allow for tri loading, which is not a good idea to use a carabiner as they are not designed for this either, and will cause them to break under much less force than normal.
    PS all carabiner that have been used under a continual load must never be used for climbing or safety afterwards as they are no longer safe and rated for the wll listed.

  • Christian1969

    This is a helpful article in general but being a novice I had trouble identifying differences between the types because none of the pictures were labeled nor was there an example of each. I had  to google each term to understand the difference. Still, thanks for the info.

  • darkedge3

    Hey great article thanks! One question which seems to have been answered so apologies but want to clarify;

    I was planning to hook 2 x 30kN caribiners for use with gymnastic rings to ceiling hooks. Based on your comments above, that doesn’t seem a good idea based on continual load, is that right? Thanks!

    • Better Trees

      You could save money and have even better security by going to your local arborist supply store and getting some stainless screw links. Anything with 1/4″ shaft or greater and made of stainless should have an intense working load. I think the WORKING load rating on 3/8ths stainless delta links is 4k, which makes the mbs 20k. A quarter of that is good for life.
      Source: I am a climbing arborist that has never fallen.

  • Better Trees

    I would like to point out that I hang my life on my aluminum oval bineers every day. They’re not made for a continuous heavy load, but the measley weight of a human is insignificant to them without substantial momentum. I climb trees and only replace aluminum life support components after shock loads. Steel pieces get replaced only when I feel like it; steel bends where aluminum breaks.
    When ascending a tree, I usually climb my rope to the canopy. Most serious climbers do. I have never heard of a beener breaking in an unreasonable circumstance.

    • larrylyons

      What would you recommend as basic tree climbing equipment? I have Buckinham saddle and spurs but want to go into trees with rope so as not to damage them.

    • BenjaminChen1

      I agree. I use to like the pear shaped ones until my friend introduced me to the DMM oval ones. Never had a problem with them side loading but a safety tip is when you clip into your friction knot slide the carabiner to the other end so the gate is above your d-ring & pointing up to the sky. Also F = MA is physics, not algebra. LOL

  • griggsy
  • gbycol

    Wtha it”s CARABINERINSTEELWITHTHREAD72KNSECURITYSYSTEM

  • gbycol

    I Need see the Picture of the product’s

  • BrianKellogg

    I’m a tower hand, we work on cell phone towers. For the last 5 years, I’ve used steel auto-locking biners for loads up to 400 pounds or so. For anything heavier we use screw shackles. Recently the safety dicks have decided even though our biners are all rated to a minimum of 22kn we can’t use those, since the working load limit isn’t stamped on the biners themselves. So I just ordered some Tuf-Tug WLL-stamped biners rated to 1500 load limit. Nice way to spend $70 of my personal money, haha. But in reality it is worth it. Less chance of dropping, one-handed operation, and rated to >2x any weight I would raise with biners. This was a pretty informative article, one I would recommend to greenhands. Also kudos to the guys at ITS, your knot of the week videos are awesome. I’ve sent the links to several new guys so they can start practicing on their own. I really liked the video of the Alpine Burtterfly, it showed it in a very simple, easy to remember technique. If you guys ever need a field review of climbing gear, let me know, we put it all through the wringer.

  • MichaelAmos1

    If a kilonewton rates force of fall, what about static?  My logic says if one kn hold 225lbs (force of fall) then static it holds significantly more, right?  If so, what’s the ratio? or rule of thumb?  I’m working on a supension trainer (like TRX), so I’m not falling onto it.

    • frankphoto2

      MichaelAmos1  I had the same Question so i googled and came up with this from science web site. So no it wont hold more weight then its Kn rating its the same.  “Pounds are generally used in the United States (and other countries) as units of weight. However, they can and are also used as units of mass, sometimes referred to as mass-pounds to reduce confusion with the http://chem.libretexts.org/Core/Analytical_Chemistry/Quantifying_Nature/Units_of_Measure/Non-SI_Units#Force.2fWeight.3a_Newton_%28N%29. Mass refers to the amount of matter in an object, while the weight refers to the downward force this object exerts in the presence of gravity. On Earth, the two values are the same.” So my next question is when you fall your 200lb body accelerates, how much force is that as measured, till your at terminal velocity in air and anywhere in between. ?

    • SiobhanColleenGee

      MichaelAmos1 A kilonewton in itself is a force. One kilonewton is equal to approximately 225 lbs. Fall forces depend on factors such as weight of the end user and free fall before the fall arrest system engages and catches the user. Static force occurs when gravity and no other forces are working on a system. For example, my static force would be approximately 0.58 kN (130 lbs) as a result from standing still. Running would produce dynamic forces. Since more forces are acting between my body and the ground, my dynamic force would be greater than my static force. Same concept in the industrial world. A rope access technician in suspension is producing less force on the system from which he hangs, than if he were to fall and create a shock load. A 180lb worker could generate an impact force that exceeds 900 lbs.

      With regards to a carabiner in an industrial situation, you are looking for a design factor of at least 5:1.

  • Matt

    This looks solely to be for recreational climbing not for professional rescue as they have to follow NFPA requirements or for professionals that work at elevation because they have to follow OSHA and ANSI. Nor is this for competent riggers because these component do not meet ASME B30.26. It would be nice to see you reference these items so that these types of professionals use the proper equipment per per the specific federal regulations and consensus standards.

  • jaimeesper

    I am just trying to find a pair carabiners that will my 360 pound weight on a hammack. The wieght of the carabiner is not a problem, I prefer steel anyway. I just dont want to fall at night. Can anyone help?

    • SiobhanColleenGee

      jaimeesper Climbing carabiners that adhere to ANSI z359.1 are required to have a minimum breaking strength of 22kN (5,000 lbs). I would worry more about the anchor points.

  • Hockeyhall03

    I am seeing a lot of construction companies using 25kn carabiners for vertical life line support. If I read your explanation about carabiners that doesn’t mean the latch meets the required 5000 lbs. They are the turn and push latch. Also using for this purpose of fall protection the loads are different and do not meet the standard. If I understand your literature about static and live loads. Can they be used for this purpose and meet OSHA regulations.

  • Extra strong carabiner

    Ok i have a carabiner i have found while doing some cleaning. The spine
    is 45 kN and the pin is 16 kN. anyone have any idea what it would be
    used for????

Do you have what you need to prevail?

Shop the ITS Store for exclusive merchandise, equipment and hard to find tactical gear.

Do you have what you need to prevail? Tap the button below to see what you’re missing.